Religion and violence

Conclusion

The massacre, far from being a senseless and inexplicable act, thus obeyed military and political logic. Beyond sectarian hatred, it was equally based on awaiting the fulfilment of prophecy and on aspects of the community and the carnavalesque of popular culture pushed to extremes. It is still relevant to try to understand why massacres come about. In fact, violence in the form of massacre was not a constant presence in the wars of religion.

St Bartholomew's Day appears to have been the apogee of the incidence of massacre. Between the end of August 1572 and the beginning of October, there were perhaps 10 000 victims, including the crisis in Paris which precipitated the massacre and its echoes in the provinces. On the Protestant side, the massacre immediately created a visceral memory which reinforced Huguenot identity: the Protestants constituted the real 'people of God', while their executioner, Charles IX[1], was a contemporary reincarnation of the Pharaoh[2]. The massacre also accelerated the political maturation of monarchomach[3] ideas and the notion of the right of resistance.

On the Catholic side, violence underwent a change in register. On the one hand, it turned in on itself towards the faithful Catholics themselves with great penitential processions through the towns supporting the League[4], the 'white processions' (especially in 1583-1584). On the other hand, there was a reaction in the form of a more coherent political project to attack the bad king; the regicides of Henri III[5] in 1589 and then Henri IV[6] in 1610 were committed in the name of God and were not a punishment of the anonymous mass of Huguenots, but of those 'politiques[7]' who had put into action a policy of civil tolerance.

  1. Charles IX

    Charles IX (1550-1574): King of France 1560 to 1574, second son of Catherine de Medici and Henri II. He remained under the influence of his mother, the regent, for a long time. He took measures to try to appease relations between Catholics and Huguenots – the Edict of St Germain (1570), the marriage of his sister to Henri de Navarre (who became Henri IV) – but he didn't stop the massacre of St Bartholomew. He died a few months later.

  2. Pharaoh

    In the books of Genesis and Exodus, the pharaohs were the rulers of Egypt who oppressed the Hebrews and reduced them to slavery, before Moses led them out of Egypt.

  3. Monarchomachs

    Term coined by an Englishman, William Barclay, in 1600 to describe a number of political theorists (Protestant but also Catholic) who argued for the right of resistance and the overthrow of tyranny. Although the principal monarchomachs were Protestant (François Hotman, Théodore de Bèze, Philippe Duplessis-Mornay and Hubert Languet), it was the Catholics who committed tyrannicide with the regicide of Henri III by the Dominican Jacques Clément in August 1589.

  4. The League

    The League was the ultra Catholic party from the years 1684-85, who were hostile to Henri III. It was formed as a result of the merging of leagues for the protection of Catholicism which had been created in the 1570s, especially in the towns in the north of the kingdom, and the Catholic party led by the Guise family. It was backed by Spain and the Papacy.

  5. Henri III

    Henri III (1551-1589): King of France 1574 to 1589, last king of the Valois dynasty. He aroused the hostility of intransigent Catholics by the way he managed the court and his government, as well as his opposition to the League. In 1588 he ordered the assassination of the leader of the League, Duke Henri de Guise. Described as the 'villain Hérodes' (anagram of Henri de Valois – the 's' seems to have been added because of the 's' in Valois) by the supporters of the League, he was assassinated in August 1589 by the Dominican Jacques Clémont.

  6. Henri IV

    Henri IV (1553-1610): King of France from 1589. First king of the Bourbon dynasty. He converted from Protestantism to Catholicism and re-established peace in France (Edict of Nantes) and abroad, notably with Spain. His political genius, his character of the bon vivant, but also his assassination, made him one of the most popular figures in the history of France.

  7. Politiques

    Term used at the time to mean individuals, moderate Catholics, who through concern for public peace and the interests of the state, supported Henri III's and then Henri VI's policy of civil tolerance.

PrécédentPrécédentSuivantSuivant
AccueilAccueilImprimerImprimer Coordination générale : Dominique Avon - Professeur à l'Université du Maine (France) Paternité - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Partage des Conditions Initiales à l'IdentiqueRéalisé avec Scenari (nouvelle fenêtre)