Religion and violence

Doctrinal influences and comparisons

The influence of the Muslim Brotherhood on the movement is a matter for debate. It is perhaps worth looking at the similarities in modes of action and doctrinal closeness of the two movements. In the 1950's Sunni writings circulated throughout the majority Muslim world; they were translated and affected the ideologues of different traditions, including Shi'ites. The Shi'ite Islamists made reference to authors such as Hassan al-Banna[1] , Abul A 'la Maududi[2] , Sheikh Taqi al-Dinal-Nabahani[3] , and Sayyid Qutb[4] . The writings of Qutb and Maududi were moreover widely translated into Persian from the 1960's, notably by Shi'ite religious journalists who had mastered Arabic. If ideas were thus circulated, they were also carried by people, or proclaimed by those attending congresses such as the one in Jerusalem.

In December 1953, The Islamic Congress for Jerusalem (al mu'tamar al-islami li-l quds) was organised on the initiative of Sheikh Amjad al-Zahawi[5] , 'alim[6] of Baghdad. Amjad al-Zahawi was none other than the co-founder, with Muhammed Mahmoud al-Sawwaf[7] , of the Iraqi branch of the Muslim Brotherhood, born in 1947. The Congress, which brought together ulemas from all over the Islamic world, took place in Old Jerusalem under the authority of the Jordanian dynasty, which had annexed Trans-Jordan. The aim of the Congress was “negotiation on the subject of Palestine and the defence of the city of Jerusalem from a probable Jewish attack.” Those sent from Iran were Ayatollahs Borujerdi, Kashani and el-Karmai, and also Navvab Safavi, whose charisma impressed both the members of the Congress and the press, according to a contemporary account given by the Iranian diplomats in Jordan to the Foreign Ministry. After the Congress, Safavi went to Egypt at the invitation of the Muslim Brotherhood. He attempted, without success, to reconcile them with Nasser[8] . Safavi was familiar with the ideas of the Brotherhood through his studies in Iraq, but this visit was his first opportunity to have direct contact with them. He spoke at a conference held at the Cairo University and called on President Neguib[9] to intervene over the Suez Canal to strike at the English and the Israelis, even though the latter were nowhere near the canal, on the basis that Egypt at that time governed the Gaza Strip. He also met Yasser Arafat[10] , who he advised him to quit his engineering studies to devote himself to the cause of the Palestinian people.

In 1955 the Feda'iyan criticised the Baghdad pact through which the United States was attempting to organise an alliance of Middle Eastern states against the USSR and her allies. In November of the same year they tried to assassinate the Iranian Prime Minister Hossein Ala[11]. Safavi and some of his comrades were arrested and executed. This event signalled the end of the Feda'iyan movement. Several groups worked to carry on his ideas, before and after the Iranian revolution of 1979.

  1. Hassan al-Banna

    Hassan al-Banna (1906-1949): Egyptian teacher and founder of the Muslim Brotherhood movement.

  2. Abul A 'la Maududi (1903-1979)

    Indo-pakistani Sunni theologian, founder of the Jamaat-e islami party.

  3. Taqi al-Dinal-Nabahani (1907-1977)

    Sunni jurist. He was the founder of the Hizb al-tahrir party after a split within the Muslim Brotherhood.

  4. Sayyid Qutb (1906-1966)

    Egyptian intellectual. Having spent time in the United States, he became the principal theoretician of the Muslim Brotherhood after the death of Hassan al-Banna.

  5. Amjad al-Zahawi

    Amjad al-Zahawi (1882-1967): Iraqi Sunni, mufti of Baghdad and president of the Association for the Relief of Palestine (jam'iyyat inqath filastin)

  6. alim

    (Pl. ulama or ulemas) -literally learned- term given to a Muslim learned in religious matters.

  7. Mohammad Mahmoud al-Sawwâf

    Muhammed Mahmoud al-Sawwaf (1914-1992): Iraqi 'alim, head of the Muslim Brotherhood in his country.

  8. Nasser

    Gamal Abdel-Nasser (1918-1970): Egyptian army officer who was the prime mover in the revolution of 1952, followed by the abolition of the monarchy. He acquired the status of an international statesman at the time of the Bandung Conference (1955), followed by the Suez crisis (1956). He was president of the Republic of Egypt from 1956 to 1970 (and of the United Arab Republic from 1958 to 1961).

  9. Neguib

    Muhammed Neguib (1901-1984): Egyptian army general, first President of the Republic of Egypt, a post he occupied from June 1953 to November 1954.

  10. Yasser Arafat

    Yasser Arafat (1929-2004): Palestinian politician, founder and head of Fatah, the movement which took over the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) in 1968.

  11. Hossein ‘Ala

    Hossein Ala (1881-1964): Iranian politician, Prime Minister from 1951 to 1957.

PrécédentPrécédentSuivantSuivant
AccueilAccueilImprimerImprimer Anaïs-Trissa Khatchadoyurian, University of Maine (France) Paternité - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de ModificationRéalisé avec Scenari (nouvelle fenêtre)