WOMEN AND RELIGIONS: PORTRAITS, ORGANISATIONS, DEBATES

The context and development of feminist theologies

Mooted by female academics, this type of theological thinking appeared in the 60s in the United States, in the wake of the Second Vatican council [1] and Ecumenical movements[2]. It is at around the same time that a Liberation Theology[3] was coalescing around combatting poverty in Latin America, as were “black” theologies, questioning “racial” hegemonies in the US.

The other driving factor was the growth of the movement for the emancipation of women. Over and above the theoretical debt to feminism acknowledged by these women's theologies, its drives were also the condition needed for the emergence of their discourse. Women were finding their voice and accessing knowledge not as individuals but as a group. They spoke up about their body as framing their experience as women and fully-fledged humans. The growing number of women accessing academic research lead to the acceptance of analytical categories allowing for the systematic deconstruction of traditional scholarship.

This new theology fully blossomed in the United States where more or less diverging trends evolved, ranging from a thoroughgoing critique to parting with Christianity, as in Mary Daly's[4] case. While, originally, theoretical thought had remained on the margins of academic scientific disciplines, it arrived in the universities in the 70s under the guise of Women's Studies[5] , and some university theology courses in the US and Canada afforded them an official setting. Elisabeth Schussler Fiorenza[6], a leading figure of this academic feminist theology in the 80s, contributed, through the translation of her works, to the dissemination of these ideas beyond the English-speaking realm. The period saw the development of those theologies in Canada's French speaking circles, notably in works by J. Lacelle[7]and Monique Dumais[8].

In Europe, feminist theologies took root in several stages. Between 1960 and 1975, theological thinking around women's status was first powered by the Second Vatican Council along with diverse post-68 youth mobilisation setups (France, Germany , Italy...). Between 1975 and 1986 a nascent feminist theology was still heavily indebted to North-American thought. As of 1968 and the creation of the European Society of Women in Theological Research ESWTR[9], it gradually attained its own, less radical stance. It essentially spread throughout the Germanic, Anglo-Saxon, Scandinavian cultural realm, very little in the French-speaking space, not at all in Central and Eastern Europe.

In the eighties, feminist theologies also spread to other continents and within ethnic minorities in North America. The diversity of their backgrounds brought forth Latino-American, African and Asian feminist theologies and a “womanist” African-American theology that seeks to conjugate the consciousness of race and gender oppressions – the former being overshadowed by feminist theology and the latter by “black” theology – along with its “mujerista” Hispano-American counterpart.

  1. Council Vatican II

    This grand gathering of the bishops of the Catholic Church programmed what has been known as its “aggiornamento”, its modernisation, be it in terms of liturgy, or in its thinking about its relation to the world.

  2. Ecumenical movements

    movements towards Christian unity and the cooperation between the diverse Christian churches. Ecumenism was a Protestant concern as early as the 19th century. Originally restricted to the Reformed churches, it came to mean a drawing together of the diverse Christian confessions at the beginning of the 20th century and brought the World Council of Churches (WCC) into being in1948. Though originally condemned by the Catholic Church ((Mortalium Animos, 1928), Vatican II finally sealed Catholic opening to ecumenism through the Decree on Ecumenism which acknowledges the Christian essence of Protestantism and encourages an on-going dialogue.

  3. Liberation Theology

    born in the years following Vatican II it was developed among others by G. Gutierrez inTeologia de la Liberacion (1971) around an axiom adopted at the conference of Medellin (1968), namely the Church's “preferential option for the poor”. A key position is the idea of a salvation effected in history and the content of which can be expressed in terms of disappearance of social evils and the construction of a just society on earth to be achieved by the dismantlement of capitalism and the advent of a classless society.

  4. Mary Daly (1928-2010)

    Catholic theologian whose book The Church and the Second Sex (1968) counts among the catalysts of feminist reactions to the Second Vatican Council. In it, she highlighted the damage caused by traditional notions of a so-called “female” nature. With the publication of Beyond God The Father (1973) her thinking marked a radical shift underscored by her leaving the Catholic Church. This paved the way to post-Christian Feminist trends. In her later works she developed a new language and a new metaphysics for women in the shape of a cosmic spiritual struggle against the destructive power of phallic structures (Pure Lust : Elemental Feminist Philosophy, 1984) and advocated lesbian separatism as the only sensible option (Gyn/Ecology, 1978).

  5. Women's studies

    interdisciplinary academic field of English speaking feminist research the first courses of which were initiated in 1970-71 at San Diego State University and at Cornell University, thereafter to experience sustained growth

  6. Elisabeth Schussler Fiorenza (1938)

    Romanian born, German educated Catholic theologian. Krister Stendahl professor of divinity at Harvard Divinity School, her book In Memory of Her : A Feminist Theological Reconstruction of Christian Origins(1983) is a turning point in feminist theology. According to her, women can rely on Jesus and early church praxis to think their own history in its current opening to feminist transformation. Her works carry the hope that one day the authority will no longer by restricted to men in the church.

  7. Elisabeth J. Lacelle (1929)

    Theologian and professor of history of Christian doctrines and institutions at the University of Ottawa where she has founded the Canadian Centre for Research on Women and Religion. Her research focuses on ecclesiology, ecumenism, women in the Christian tradition. Elisabeth Lacelle was a consultant to the conference of Canadian Catholic bishops between 1971 and 1984. She is also one of the founders of the network “Women and Ministry” which works towards the acknowledgment of women's ministry.

  8. Monique Dumais (1939)

    Ursuline nun, professor of theology and ethics at the Université of Quebec at Rimouski, she has focussed her research on the relation between women and the Catholic Church and on ethics in the feminist discourse. She is one of the founders of the Catholic feminist group “L'Autre parole” and of its review in 1970. She is also involved in the network Women and Ministry which works towards the acknowledgment of women's ministry.

  9. Association des Femmes d'Europe pour la Recherche théologique (AFERT) ou European Society of Women in Theological Research

    European Society of Women in Theological Research (ESWTR): network of female academics in the field of theology or religious sciences founded in 1986. They publish the yearly Journal of the European Society of Women in Theological Research, organise encounters at regional and national level as well as a European conference every other year

PrécédentPrécédentSuivantSuivant
AccueilAccueilImprimerImprimer Overall coordination by Dominique Avon Professor at the Le Mans Université (France) - Translation by Françoise Pinteaux-Jones Paternité - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de ModificationRéalisé avec Scenari (nouvelle fenêtre)